The silent finding

Watch

LMNT Neurotherapy Diagnostic Pain Points

Explained

Navel Liv°Mu°

for constipation

Given by a therapist

Const

Gal Point (Gallbladder) - How to Give 1 Gal, 3 Gal & 1 Point Gal | Practical Training for Students

Given by a therapist

Gall bladder Gal

The silent finding

Minuses, and the tenderness the patient never knew she had

A patient comes because something hurts. She can tell you where, when and how much, and has told several people already. That complaint is the least interesting thing you will learn about her, because she already knew it. What she does not know is what your fingers are about to find.

Key teaching

The pain the patient does not know she has

Very often the tenderness you find is a tenderness the patient did not know was there until it was found.

Nothing in an ordinary life presses two fingers into that square inch and leans: a knee announces itself because she walks on it, while a place two inches left of the navel has never once been asked a question. So the ordinary sound of a first examination is not a complaint but a question — "What is that? Why is there pain there? There has never been pain there."

And the working consequence: what you discover frequently matters more than what she came in complaining of. The complaint tells you where she feels the trouble; the findings tell you where it is coming from. Those are often two different places, and the treatment follows the second.

Two rules come with that. Do not announce the discovery as a revelation — a patient told "your liver is blocked" will believe it for a year, and frightening explanations produce real symptoms in real bodies. Say instead: "There is a tender place here. In our system this one is connected with the working of the liver, and it is one of the things we will work on. It does not mean there is damage." And do not treat the complaint as a distraction: she came about her knees, so say on day one that you will be working on her digestion and why, and say it again in week two.

A student's instinct is that a minus is a blank. That is exactly backwards.

Key teaching

A minus is a positive statement

If the skin or fat feels soft like butter and the patient gives no reaction at all on pressing, then the blood circulation below that part is entirely correct.

That is a finding, and it does three jobs.

It rules something out — a quiet Const in a patient complaining of hard motions changes what you look for next. And it calibrates the pluses: a card with eighteen pluses is not a diagnosis but a confession, because a therapist who found no minuses was pressing too hard and every grade on it is suspect. A good examination almost always has minuses on it.

It is the baseline that lets a change be seen. A point reading minus this week and two plus next week has moved — which an empty box would never have shown you.

The most satisfying silence arrives later. A point three plus at the first visit and one plus at the fourth has told you what no conversation can: if the pain at a place is relieved, the blood supply to that place has been restored.

The four ways to manufacture a tenderness that is not there

Too hard, too long, the wrong place, and the leading question

Everything above tells you how to find what is there; this tells you how therapists routinely find what is not. Every one of the four feels, at the time, like doing the job properly. They are: pressing too hard · pressing too long · pressing in the wrong direction or over the wrong structure · leading the patient with the question. Three are your hand. The fourth is your mouth, and it is the one almost every student commits in the first month without noticing.

One — pressing too hard

Two — pressing too long

Three — pressing in the wrong direction, or over the wrong structure

Nothing about this one feels like an error: the therapist is gentle, brief, and standing in the right place. He is simply not pressing where he thinks he is.

Four — leading the patient with the question

This is the one almost nobody escapes, and the hardest to see in yourself, because it does not live in the hand at all.

A MISTAKE STUDENTS MAKE

The press that would hurt anybody

A student is not finding much. Four patients, mostly minuses, and it feels like failure — as though a real therapist would have found more. So on the fifth he presses a little harder, and the findings come.

What has gone wrong. Enough pressure produces tenderness in any tissue, healthy or not, so a press hard enough to hurt everybody is a test positive in everybody — and that carries no information. He has not found eleven pain points; he has made eleven, and will treat them tomorrow at stations chosen by findings that were never there. A second cost shows a fortnight later: the patient, raised not to complain to somebody who is helping her, says nothing, goes home sore, and is "too busy to come" next week. You will record that as a patient who stopped attending, and never connect it to your thumb.

The correction.

Recalibrate on yourself, weekly. Press two fingertips into the soft belly of your own forearm, just below the elbow, until you first feel firm resistance — not until it hurts. That is roughly the pressure that reaches two plus; beyond it is manufacture.

Recalibrate on a known belly. A healthy young belly should give mostly minuses; if it does not, the fault is in your hand, not your relatives.

Take the softest possible press first, and aim for minuses. Four plus is defined by what the patient does at the very lightest touch, so if you begin heavy you have skipped the rung that defines the scale — and a therapist hunting for findings will find them. ▲ Take care

A MISTAKE STUDENTS MAKE

The press that is held until something happens

A student presses, feels nothing definite, and keeps pressing while he decides. Three seconds. Five. He is being thorough. By eight seconds the patient shifts and says "yes, a little, there."

What has gone wrong. He has leaned on a small area until the tissue beneath it complained — not a diagnostic finding but what sustained pressure does, as a hard chair eventually aches. Worse, his own instrument went deaf while he waited: nerve endings stop reporting a pressure that does not change, so the longer he held, the less he could feel. And a confusion sits underneath it. Six seconds is the unit of treatment, not of examination. 6 sec A student fresh from learning to count six holds an examining press for six out of habit — and has given a small treatment at a diagnostic point without meaning to, which not only manufactures a finding but changes the thing he was trying to measure.

The correction.

Two seconds in, one or two seconds there, out. If you have not got your answer by then, staying will not give it to you.

When unsure, release and press again rather than pressing longer — all the information is in the change — or leave the point and come back at the end. And count nothing during an examination: counting belongs to treatment, and here you are looking at a face.

A MISTAKE STUDENTS MAKE

Pressing on bone, and pressing downhill

The wrong structure. He is looking for Gal under the right rib margin and his fingers are resting on the rib margin itself. Bone under a fingertip reads as absolute hardness — the finger is stopped instantly, which on the scale is three or four plus — and the tissue lining a bone is tender in everybody. He writes Gal ++++. He has graded a rib.

The fault has half a dozen faces. At Pan he presses the little bony spur at the bottom of the breastbone instead of the soft dip beside it, and almost every patient alive flinches. At Acid, Fluid, FA and B₁₂ he presses the hard rim of the hip crest instead of the soft strip above it; at the flank, the last rib; above and left of the navel, the great artery. At WD he presses a bladder that was not emptied — which is why the patient passes urine first — and at Gas 'I' a gas-filled loop springs back and he records hardness where there is only wind.

The wrong direction. He kneels too high, looks down at the back of his own hand, and presses towards the floor at every point. On the flat of the belly that is correct. At the flank, where the surface is nearly vertical, it drives the fingers along the wall instead of into it — a smear of soreness belonging to no point; over the slope of the rib margin it slides his fingers off the point altogether.

The correction.

Find the point from bone every time. The landmarks that do not move are the bottom tip of the breastbone, the two rib margins, the crest of the hip bone, the bony knob at the front of the hip, and the navel. Walk to the point from a landmark on this body, this morning.

Press beside bone, never on it. If your fingertip is stopped instantly and completely, look at what you are on: bone stops a finger the way a table does, and tissue never quite does.

Go in at right angles to the skin at that place — at the flank, horizontally in from the side with the patient turned; at the rib margin, angling in and slightly up under the margin. Side-lying Prone

Learn the three impostors by feel. Bone — instant, unyielding, its edge traceable. Artery — soft, cord-like, and it beats. Gas — springy, it gives and comes back, and it moves if you wait. And have the patient bend her knees up when the wall is hard and the landmarks disappear.

A MISTAKE STUDENTS MAKE

"That hurts, doesn't it?"

He presses at Const, and because the history already made him suspect the bowel, he asks: "That one's painful, isn't it?" She says yes. He writes three plus.

What has gone wrong. He has asked a question with the answer inside it, of a person lying on her back, half undressed, in a room she does not know, being helped by a man she is anxious to please. She will agree; most people will, because to say "no" is to contradict the expert. And it is not only the words: he also named the point aloud while pressing it, paused longer where he expected something, pressed a little harder without deciding to, and drew in a breath when his finger arrived. She read every one of those signals correctly — he has run the whole examination as a conversation about what he already believed.

The correction.

Press first and say nothing. Take your grade from the face and the finger before a word is spoken.

If you must ask, ask the same neutral question everywhere — "tell me what you feel here." Not "does that hurt?", which offers a yes; not "tell me when it hurts", which promises that it will. And ask it at the quiet points too: asking only where you expect something is itself the leading.

Give her a reference before you begin. Press once where you expect silence and say: "That is how most of them will feel. Tell me if any place feels different." Now she is comparing, which she can do honestly, instead of judging, which she cannot.

Do not name the point while you are on it, and keep one tempo — your rhythm is a question you did not know you were asking. Grade from your finger first, then let her words move it: if the wall was soft as butter and she says it hurts, that disagreement is worth a note, not an automatic three plus.

The order of examination

Flanks first, away from the complaint, outer ring inward

A therapist who examines in a different order every day is running a different test every day. Fix an order and keep it. Four reasons build the one taught here, and they matter more than the sequence.

Start where the answer sorts the most. The two flanks come first, because what they say against each other divides patients into two great families and a large part of the plan follows.

Start away from the complaint. The first press of a session teaches the patient what pressing feels like; a first press at the sore place teaches her to brace, and every reading after that comes from a braced wall.

Work from the outer ring inward. The outer points sit over firmer ground and tolerate examination best, while the field around the navel is the most sensitive part of the abdomen in almost everybody. Outside-in, an irritated inner ring never contaminates your outer readings; inside-out, it does, every time. And keep the pairs together — right member, then left, then on.

THE METHOD, STEP BY STEP

The route of the examining hand

Before anything. Hands warm, nails short, the patient placed, covered and told what is about to happen; card and pencil beside your knee.

One — the two flanks. Turned onto her side, or reached round to: the soft place between the last rib and the rim of the hip bone. Liv° right first, then Mu° left, pressing gently and horizontally into the body. Write both, even when both are minuses. Right Left

Two — the upper field, outer ring. Supine, pillow under both thighs, none under the head unless needed. Gal under the right rib margin, then Spl under the left; then Pan, in the soft dip at the bottom of the breastbone. Supine

Three — the middle ring. Dys right of the midline, then Const left; then Gas, midline between breastbone and navel; then, level with the navel, Liv right and Mu left.

Four — the navel itself. Gas 'I', immediately around it — the most sensitive ground on the chart, and the reason it comes late.

Five — below the navel and the rim. WD on the midline; then Rt.Ov, then Lt.Ov, each midway along the line from navel to the bony knob at the front of that hip. Then Fluid over the right groin and crest, Acid over the left; FA right and B₁₂ left at the front of the crests, Thia right and Nia left above the back of them. Side-lying

At every stage: grade, write, move.

If a patient cannot be turned, do the flanks last, knees bent, and note on the card that they were done at the end. If a region is under caution — a fresh scar, a stoma, a known swelling, a pregnancy, a rigid belly — you do not examine it, and you write down that you did not, and why. ▲ Take care (Figure 7.3)

The route of the examining hand. The settled order of examination on a front-view trunk: the two flanks first, then the upper field, the middle ring, the navel, and below the navel to the rim — right member of each pair before the left.

Recording what you find

Grade, write, move: the card as the instrument of comparison

Asked why he keeps no records to show the world, Guruji answers: "In the time I would have to spend every day making written records to show to others, I could serve another fifteen or twenty lakh patients." That is a man choosing the patient in front of him over the notebook, every day for fifty years, and nobody who has run a free clinic will sneer at it.

But notice what was declined: a record kept to show to others. The card beside the mat is a different object — the instrument that lets today's session be compared with last Tuesday's. Without it there is no comparison, and without comparison this therapy loses the one thing that tells it whether it is working. A therapist who does not write cannot know; he can only feel that things are going well, and feelings favour whoever holds them.

Key teaching

Write it at the moment you make it

Grade, write, move. Not grade, grade, grade, then write.

A grade decays in about a minute. Four points later, "was that two plus or three plus?" has no honest answer, and you will resolve it in whichever direction fits the story you have begun telling yourself. And eighteen findings will not survive to the end of an examination: you will remember three — the loudest, the first, and the one you expected, which is a summary of your own expectations and not a record. Writing at the point also slows you down, which is a benefit: those two seconds are when you decide what you actually felt.

THE METHOD, STEP BY STEP

The card as it is written at the mat

The date, and the time relative to food — "14.3 · 11 a.m. · two hours after a light breakfast." A belly examined an hour after a heavy meal is not the same belly. Note the position she was in, and any departure from the route.

The findings, in route order, each as point · side · ring · grade · H or P — every point examined, minuses included — and the patient's own words in quotation marks where they are worth keeping; her words are evidence, your paraphrase an opinion.

Anything that made her worse. In the gap after each formula you must ask how she is feeling, and if the trouble increases after any point or formula, take the chief therapist's opinion at once as to whether the treatment should be changed — and write this clearly on the card, so that in future that point is not given again, or, if it must be given, so that proper caution is taken. ▲ Take care This entry outranks everything else here.

Sugar or BP, and whatever she takes for them, marked in its proper place and told to the chief therapist — many patients do not think of a daily tablet as a medicine until asked. Then your initials.

Part of one card. Four paired lines of a patient's card, read whole: minuses show the hand was calibrated, and the pluses gather on one side — a pattern rather than a scatter.

Read a card whole rather than line by line and two things declare themselves: there are minuses on it, so the hand was calibrated; and the pluses cluster on one side, a pattern rather than a scatter. What the pattern means is the next article's business. (Figure 7.4)

Two bodies, read with the fingers

A migraine read as a bowel, and a man who never said it hurt

A CASE FROM PRACTICE

The housewife who came about her migraine and left talking about her bowel

A composite case, assembled to teach the reasoning rather than taken from one patient's file.

Sushila Deshpande · 46 · housewife · Sangli · came with headaches three or four days a week for six years

What she came with, in her own words. "It starts here" — the right temple — "by eleven o'clock, and by evening I am finished." Asked what else, she said nothing, twice. Asked differently — "and motions, how are they?" — "normal". Asked exactly — "every day? and does it come easily?" — "every second or third day. With effort. But that is normal for ladies, no?"

What was observed and palpated. She walked in holding her handbag against her upper belly, which people do without knowing it. A soft-looking abdomen that was not soft. Warm hands, short nails, the standard route, everything written at the point. Flanks first: Liv° R −, Mu° L ++ H. Then the front, outer ring inward: Gal R 1 +, Spl L 1 −; Const L 2 ++++ — she came off the mat and said "What is that? There has never been pain there" — with Dys R 2 − beside it; Mu L 2 +++ H, Gas 'I' 3 + P; below the navel silent, both crests silent but B₁₂ L +. Nine of the eighteen were minuses.

Several complaints read as one picture. Not a headache and a bowel and a dry mouth, but one direction with three faces: hard, infrequent, effortful stools; a mouth she called "always dry, I keep a glass by me"; a headache arriving late in the morning at the same hour. The left-sided cluster was a pattern, not a scatter.

Which reports mattered. A normal scan of the head from two years earlier changed nothing. Her haemoglobin mattered, her periods having been heavy for a year and never checked. The B₁₂ finding, with no symptoms of deficiency, was a prompt and nothing more: noted, not acted on.

What was chosen, and why. Nothing aimed at the head: the Const and Mu findings said where the work lay, the ring numbers said where on the limbs. She was told on day one, and again on day three, that her digestion was being treated and the headache expected to follow.

Session by session, and what was done when it stopped working. Week one: motions daily by the sixth day, and she mentioned it before she mentioned her head; Const down to +++, then ++. Week two: two headaches. Week three: nothing moved, Const stuck at ++, headaches back to four. She was re-examined from the beginning as though it were a first visit, and the card had moved in a way the plan had not: Const almost quiet at the middle ring, newly tender at the inner ring close to the navel. The tenderness had not gone; it had moved inward — and a treatment given at the station answering the middle ring does very little for a finding at the inner one. The station was changed, not the point.

What went wrong because something was withheld. In week five she slid back. Asked not "are you taking anything?" — to which she had said no three times — but "show me what you put in your mouth yesterday, from waking", she arrived at four tablets a day of a painkiller taken since the migraines began, which she did not count as a medicine because it was sold beside the toothpaste. She was not told to stop it; she went to her own doctor with her card, and that doctor changed it.

What this case teaches

She came about her head and the fingers answered about her bowel — and she did not know the Const point was tender, which is the ordinary case, not the exception.

Nine minuses are as much a finding as nine pluses, and they are the evidence that the hand was calibrated. A finding can move inward without going away: record the ring, or you cannot see it happen.

"How are motions?" gets "normal". "Every day? And does it come easily?" gets the truth.

A CASE FROM PRACTICE

The mill worker who never once said that anything hurt

A composite case, assembled to teach the reading of hardness in a patient who will not report pain.

Ramzan Ali · 58 · power-loom operator, thirty-one years at the same machine · Bhiwandi · came because his son brought him, for swelling of the feet and breathlessness on the stairs

What he came with, in his own words. Very little. "Thoda sa hai" — "it is only a little." His son supplied the history: two years of it, worse in the last six months, from a man who had never missed a shift and never been to a doctor.

What was observed and palpated. He lay down without being told twice and flinched at nothing; the whole first examination produced not one word from him. The fingers, however, were stopped early again and again: Liv° R +++ H against Mu° L +, taken within a minute and confirmed on a second pass, then Gal R 1 +++ H, Spl L 1 −, Const L 2 ++ H, Gas 2 +++ H. Every finding carried an H and not one carried a P. A student grading from the report rather than from his own finger would have called the man fine. Hardness is not an opinion, and thirty-one years of not admitting to discomfort at a loom does not switch off because a man has lain down on a mat.

Which reports mattered, and where the hand stopped. Swelling of both feet with breathlessness on exertion in a man of fifty-eight is not a finding to answer with another session. He was sent the same day with a letter, and the therapy waited. His kidney function and his heart were looked at properly for the first time in his life, and both needed attention. The therapist did not stop treating him; he stopped being the only person treating him.

What was chosen, and what followed. Treatment alongside what his physician had begun, never instead of it, the hard Gal and Gas read as one picture rather than two complaints. Because he would never say a press was too much, the pressure was set from the wall and the face, and the son was asked each week whether his father had been sore afterwards. By the third week the Gas hardness had gone from +++ to ++ — which nobody could see and everybody could measure, because it had been written down — and his son reported him climbing the stairs in one go.

What went wrong because something was withheld. In the sixth week his ankles were worse again with nothing changed in the plan. Asked in front of his son, it emerged that he had stopped one of his physician's two tablets, because "I am taking treatment here now, so why two things?" Nobody had told him that; he had worked it out for himself, which is what patients do in the silence you leave. He was told what should have been said on day one — we use no medicine of any kind, and we do not tell you to stop yours — and it was written on his card.

What this case teaches

The finger and the face are two witnesses, and sometimes only one of them speaks. Compare the two flanks within a minute and confirm on a second pass.

A card of all-H and no-P is itself a finding about the patient, worth a line in the notes. And swollen feet and breathlessness are not points on a chart: knowing which findings leave the room is a clinical skill.

Say the rule about medicines out loud on day one, or the patient will invent his own version and act on it.

Training your own hand

Well bellies, kept cards, and two therapists checking each other

THE METHOD, STEP BY STEP

The first eight weeks of a hand

Examine well people — family, fellow students, neighbours with no complaint at all. Six points each: Gal, Spl, Liv, Mu, Const, Dys. Write the card. A well belly should give you mostly minuses, and when it stops giving you pluses your press has come down to the right weight. Beginners skip this because it feels as though nothing is happening; it is the most valuable thing they could do.

Ten a week, and keep the cards — a finding only means something in comparison, and in your first month you have nothing to compare against. Re-examine the same person on two days, and where two cards disagree about a body that has not changed, that is your error.

Have two therapists examine the same three patients, each writing his card without seeing the other's; then put the cards side by side. Where you disagree — and you will, especially between one plus and two plus — is where your training needs work. A hand drifts, and it drifts without telling you.

Keep the six-second count separately trained — with a friend and a watch, daily, until you change position at exactly six without counting. 6 sec It belongs to the treatment; the point of training it is so that it never leaks into your examination.

The educated hand. The whole article on one page: what is measured, how to press, the five grades, the four ways a tenderness is manufactured, the order of examination and how a finding is written.

WHAT TO CARRY AWAY

You are not measuring pain. You are measuring how far your finger travelled before something pushed back, and what the patient's face did while it travelled. Both go on the card.

How to press: nails short, hands warm; two or three fingers side by side, pads flat, the bend at the big knuckles, wrist straight; kneel level with her hip so the forearm comes in parallel to the mat, the weight coming from a leaning trunk through a soft arm and never from squeezing fingers. Warn · land flat · wait for the out-breath · sink slowly, about two seconds, straight in at right angles to the skin · stop where you are stopped · hold a second or two · watch the face · release slowly · lift clear · place, never slide · keep one tempo.

The scale: ++++ cries out at the very lightest touch · +++ stiffness or pain once the finger has gone a little way in · ++ surface soft, stiffness somewhat deeper · + soft quite deep down, then a mild stiffness · − soft like butter and no reaction at all, meaning the blood circulation below that part is entirely correct. Plus means pain; minus means no pain.

A finding is written point · side · ring · grade · H or P — the ring because it decides the station on the limb. An empty box means not examined; a minus means examined and silent. Write at the point, not afterwards. Hardness — kaḍakpan — is not tenderness: it is what your finger meets and does not depend on the patient's temperament, and in the patient who will not complain it may be the only reading you get.

Compare left with right, one after the other, within a minute, never one alone; then today's card against her own from last week. A silent point is a finding, and a card with no minuses is a confession rather than a diagnosis — the tenderness you find is very often one the patient did not know she had, and what you discover matters more than what she came in complaining of.

Four ways to manufacture a tenderness that is not there: pressing too hard · pressing too long · pressing in the wrong direction or over the wrong structure · leading the patient with the question. Corrections in order: lightest press first, expect minuses; two seconds in, a second there, out — six seconds is treatment, not examination; find the point from bone and press beside it, at right angles to the skin; press and say nothing, and ask the same neutral words everywhere.

The order of the hand: the two flanks first; then away from the complaint; then the outer ring inward, each pair together, ending at the rim. Small children, very weak persons and any patient with osteoporosis are examined and treated with the hand only.

Language

The silent finding

Watch

The silent finding

The pain the patient does not know she has

A minus is a positive statement

The four ways to manufacture a tenderness that is not there

One — pressing too hard

Two — pressing too long

Three — pressing in the wrong direction, or over the wrong structure

Four — leading the patient with the question

The order of examination

Recording what you find

Write it at the moment you make it

Two bodies, read with the fingers

Training your own hand

Ready to begin?